Drones in Surveying: LiDAR vs. Photogrammetry – Insights from the Field
The surveying industry is constantly evolving, and the integration of drone technology has brought about a significant shift in how professionals approach land measurement and mapping. For those of us in the pilot’s seat, we’ve witnessed firsthand the transformative power of drones equipped with specialized sensors. When it comes to creating accurate and detailed geospatial data, the debate often centers around two primary technologies: LiDAR and photogrammetry. Choosing the right tool for the job is critical for efficiency, accuracy, and project success. These curated YouTube videos offer valuable on-the-ground perspectives and practical insights into leveraging drones for land surveying, specifically addressing the nuances of LiDAR and photogrammetry workflows. Let’s dive into the key takeaways and explore how these technologies are being implemented in real-world surveying scenarios.
Key Insights from Drone Surveying Videos
-
LiDAR for Speed and Penetration (Video 1 & 2): The "Land Surveying with Drone LiDAR | On the job!" video highlights the operational advantages of LiDAR in a professional surveying context. MooreBass Civil Engineering emphasizes that drone LiDAR allows them to complete projects faster and safer. This is echoed in the "How-to Fly Drone LiDAR! (Land Surveying) | #shorts" video, showcasing the practical application of LiDAR technology. Key takeaway: LiDAR excels in situations demanding rapid data acquisition and when vegetation penetration is necessary to map the bare earth accurately. Think dense forests or areas with heavy undergrowth where traditional photogrammetry might struggle to reach the ground surface effectively.
-
Photogrammetry for Accessible 3D Modeling (Video 3): "Aerial Photogrammetry Explained – Create 3D Models With Drone Photos" provides a clear explanation of how photogrammetry works. It emphasizes the process of triangulating points from overlapping images to generate 3D models. Dronegenuity, a provider of drone services, underscores the accessibility of photogrammetry for creating accurate 3D models from aerial photos. Key takeaway: Photogrammetry offers a more accessible entry point for 3D modeling, utilizing visual data readily captured by standard drone cameras. This method is particularly effective in open areas and for applications where detailed surface texture and visual representation are important.
-
Software and Processing Efficiency (Video 4): "I Tested WebODM and Found the FASTEST Way to Process Photos!" focuses on the crucial aspect of data processing. This video demonstrates the use of WebODM, a free software, for processing drone mapping data, including Ground Control Points (GCPs). Stefan Engineering highlights the cost-effectiveness and accessibility of WebODM, making drone mapping workflows more attainable. Key takeaway: Efficient data processing is just as vital as data collection. Open-source and accessible software like WebODM democratize drone mapping, enabling surveyors to manage and process photogrammetric data effectively without significant software investments.
Flash Bill Ten Pack ($5.00) - $15.00 Printed on one side, you can't tell from a distant whether it's the real bill or a fake one. Excellent for close-up magic. No smoke and ash left after burning. Pack contains ten U.S. bill-sized sheets of flash paper.
4 Gallon 6.0 Peak HP Detachable Blower Wet/Dry Vac - $118.99No matter when and where the mess strikes, stay on top of it with this compact, lightweight shop vacuum. The highly portable design is perfect for quick pick-ups around the house. Never before have we offered so much power and versatility in one portable package. The impressive 6.0 peak HP motor can handle any task, and when detached will blow you away.
Cheech & Chong's Up In Smoke Beaker Bong - $89.80 Cheech & Chong's Up In Smoke Beaker Bong This Cheech & Chong beaker-style water pipe stands 7.25 inches tall with attached downstem and 14mm male bowl. Pipe comes in assorted colors. Officially licensed. Available colors are dependent on current inventory. HIGHLIGHTS 7.25"" tall: Provides a compact yet effective size for easy handling and storage. 14mm female pipe: Ensures compatibility with a variety of accessories. Attached downstem diffuser: Enhances the smoking experience by providing smooth, filtered hits. Beaker style with bent neck: Offers stability and a comfortable smoking angle. Includes 14mm male herb slide: Conveniently allows for the use of dry herbs. Colors vary: Adds a fun element of surprise and individuality to each purchase.
JGO Magic Mushroom Gummies, 5000 mg, 20 ct - $31.99
from: Headshop.com
DJI Mavic Air 12MP 4K Foldable 3-Axis Gimbal Obstacle Avoidance Panoramas FPV Quadcopter RC Selfie Drone - $1,211.71 features high-end flight performance and functionality for limitless exploration..
-
VTOL Fixed-Wing Drones for Large Area Surveys (Video 5): The "CW-40 VTOL fixed-wing UAV- best drone for surveying" video showcases a specific drone platform, the JOUAV CW-40 VTOL, designed for surveying. It emphasizes the efficiency of VTOL fixed-wing drones for large-scale land surveying projects. Key takeaway: For extensive survey areas, VTOL fixed-wing drones combine the vertical takeoff and landing capabilities of multirotors with the endurance and speed of fixed-wing aircraft. This platform becomes particularly advantageous when covering vast terrains efficiently, maximizing data collection in a single flight.
-
Understanding Drone Surveying Options (Video 6): "Top 10 Surveying Drones: Features and Benefits Explained" offers a broader overview of various drone models available for surveying. While it lists consumer-grade drones, it implicitly highlights the range of options and price points in the market. It’s important to note that while some listed drones might be suitable for basic tasks, professional surveying demands higher precision and sensor capabilities, often found in more specialized platforms. Key takeaway: The drone market offers a spectrum of options, but for professional land surveying, particularly when comparing LiDAR and photogrammetry, focusing on drones designed for accurate data acquisition with appropriate sensors and RTK/PPK capabilities is paramount. The video serves as a starting point for understanding the diverse market but further research into survey-grade drones is essential.
Practical Considerations: LiDAR vs. Photogrammetry in the Field
From a pilot’s perspective, the choice between LiDAR and photogrammetry often boils down to project requirements and environmental conditions. LiDAR missions, while potentially faster in data acquisition, can be more demanding in terms of flight planning and execution, especially to ensure complete coverage and data integrity. The sensor payload is typically heavier, influencing drone selection and flight endurance. However, the ability of LiDAR to penetrate vegetation and directly measure ground elevation in challenging environments provides unparalleled advantages for certain projects.
Photogrammetry missions, on the other hand, often involve longer flight times to capture sufficient overlapping imagery. Careful flight planning is crucial to maintain consistent image overlap and ensure accurate 3D reconstruction. While processing photogrammetric data can be computationally intensive, advancements in software and cloud processing are streamlining these workflows. The visual nature of photogrammetry also provides valuable orthomosaics and textured 3D models, enhancing the interpretability of survey data.
Cheech & Chong's Up In Smoke Beaker Bong - $89.80 Cheech & Chong's Up In Smoke Beaker Bong This Cheech & Chong beaker-style water pipe stands 7.25 inches tall with attached downstem and 14mm male bowl. Pipe comes in assorted colors. Officially licensed. Available colors are dependent on current inventory. HIGHLIGHTS 7.25"" tall: Provides a compact yet effective size for easy handling and storage. 14mm female pipe: Ensures compatibility with a variety of accessories. Attached downstem diffuser: Enhances the smoking experience by providing smooth, filtered hits. Beaker style with bent neck: Offers stability and a comfortable smoking angle. Includes 14mm male herb slide: Conveniently allows for the use of dry herbs. Colors vary: Adds a fun element of surprise and individuality to each purchase.
4 Gallon 6.0 Peak HP Detachable Blower Wet/Dry Vac - $118.99No matter when and where the mess strikes, stay on top of it with this compact, lightweight shop vacuum. The highly portable design is perfect for quick pick-ups around the house. Never before have we offered so much power and versatility in one portable package. The impressive 6.0 peak HP motor can handle any task, and when detached will blow you away.
JGO Magic Mushroom Gummies, 5000 mg, 20 ct - $31.99
from: Headshop.comDJI Mavic Air 12MP 4K Foldable 3-Axis Gimbal Obstacle Avoidance Panoramas FPV Quadcopter RC Selfie Drone - $1,211.71 features high-end flight performance and functionality for limitless exploration..
Flash Bill Ten Pack ($5.00) - $15.00 Printed on one side, you can't tell from a distant whether it's the real bill or a fake one. Excellent for close-up magic. No smoke and ash left after burning. Pack contains ten U.S. bill-sized sheets of flash paper.
Ultimately, both LiDAR and photogrammetry are powerful tools in the surveyor’s arsenal. The "best" technology isn’t universal; it’s project-dependent. Factors like vegetation density, required accuracy, project scale, budget, and deliverables all play a role in determining the optimal approach.
Explore the Video Highlights Below
To gain a deeper understanding of these technologies in action and hear directly from professionals in the field, we encourage you to explore the video highlights below. Each video offers a unique perspective and practical insights that will help you navigate the landscape of best land surveying drones and make informed decisions for your surveying needs.
Continue below to watch the videos
About the Author
